Q: Can the microphone in your design be replaced [to good effect] by a high-end
studio USB mic ? I would like to build something a bit "upper scale" to record the
birds in our
woods [as well as migratory flights overhead].
Cite Ref: Rode Microphones Podcaster USB Microphone
http://www.amazon.com/Rode-Microphones-Podcaster-USB-Microphone/dp/B000JM46FY/ref=tag_dpp_lp_edpp_ttl_in
*******************
A: Yes, any mic will work. Mics can be optimized for specific goals. The Knowles
mic element we recommend for avian night flight call recording has a freqency
response that is optimized for picking up the flight calls of most night-migrating songbirds in North America. It has a 12 dB per octave rolloff
below 2kHz. This is very useful for limiting wind thumping, jet, and
auto noise resulting in a cleaner signal for the 100 or so night-migrating
birds that have flight calls above 2 kHz. Almost all commercially
available mics such as the one you mention have much better low frequency
response. But those won't be as functional for recording night migrating
songbirds for most rooftop microphone location. They would work
just fine if the mic is located in a sheltered, wind-free location or on
nights with light winds. But imagine a 20 mph wind directly buffeting a
microphone. Even in the flowerpot protective structure, wind noise would be a
significant issue.
A higher end mic with flatter frequency response will provide a more
accurate sound recording if you want to record birds in the woods and listen back
for enjoyment but, as mentioned, it is not as functional for general avian
night flight call recording. If you want to do both, a higher end commercially
available mic is certainly one way to go, though the Knowles mic element can be used effectively for recording birdsong in the woods.
A benefit of buying a commercially available mic is that is will have more
sophisticated electronics that will better at limiting electronic interference. The mic design offered here is about the simplest
electronic design possible and was offered to encourage beginners to get
involved.
You will also have to consider how you will mount other mics to
gain the amplification benefits of the PZM. If you want to amplify the
low frequencies equally with the highs, you will need a larger boundary (the
breadth of which equal to the length of the lowest freq you want to amplify).